right signal
Pick Best overall LLM

Claude Fable 5.1

As of 14 Sep 2026, Claude Fable 5.1 is the RightSignal pick for best overall LLM.

Joint first on the re-based Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v4.3 (53, level with GPT-6 Astra), first on the official Terminal-Bench v4.0 board at 57.9%, and first on Vellum's quality/speed/cost composite at 65%.

Current pick
since 10 Sep 2026
4
days as pick
Reign history
4days
current reign
0challenges
held off
10 SEP 2026became pick
0previous
reigns
Last reviewed: 10 Sep 2026 Reviews are continuous. This pick can change when the evidence changes.

Why Claude Fable 5.1 is the pick

  • Joint first on the re-based Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v4.3 (53, level with GPT-6 Astra), first on the official Terminal-Bench v4.0 board at 57.9%, and first on Vellum's quality/speed/cost composite at 65%.
  • On Arena text it sits at 1504 inside a 1-6 tie band with the rest of the Anthropic top group.
  • Costs more per Index task than GPT-6 Astra ($7.63 against $3.26), so price the alternative if volume matters.
Judged on reasoning quality · multimodal capability · long-context reliability · independent benchmarks

Evidence

The sources behind this title’s record.

Vendor numbers are treated as claims until independently reproduced — how we judge. Structured benchmark comparisons are on the roadmap.

Caveats & challengers

  • The Arena text board is tight at the top: on the 2 September snapshot Fable 5 leads at 1507 with a rank spread of 1-6, with Claude Opus 4.6 (high) on 1505, Claude Fable 5.1 (max) on 1504 and Meta's Muse Spark 1.2 (xHigh) on 1499, so treat the lead as first-among-equals and read the exact tie band off the live board.
  • Artificial Analysis has re-based its Intelligence Index twice this month, and on v4.3 Claude Fable 5.1 (max) and GPT-6 Astra (max) share first place on 53, ahead of Claude Opus 5 on 51 and Fable 5 itself on 50, with Astra costing $3.26 per Index task against Fable 5.1's $7.63.
  • Terminal-Bench has moved on too: the official board now runs v4.0, where Fable 5.1 leads on 57.9%, Opus 5 scores 51.8% and Fable 5 44.5%, so the old 83.8% figure from the 2.1 board no longer describes current terminal work.

At a glance

Title
Best overall LLM
Licence
proprietary
Pick since
10 Sep 2026
Last reviewed
10 Sep 2026
Title holders to date
10
Official page
www.anthropic.com/claude/fable

Title history

Every change, on the record.

View full changelog
Pick 10 Sep 2026 – presentClaude Fable 5.1 Current

Joint first on the re-based Artificial Analysis Intelligence Index v4.3 (53, level with GPT-6 Astra), first on the official Terminal-Bench v4.0 board at 57.9%, and first on Vellum's quality/speed/cost composite at 65%.

4 days
as pick
Pick 1 Jul 2026 – 10 Sep 2026Claude Fable 5

Number one on the Arena text leaderboard at 1506 Elo, having redeployed globally on 1 July after its 9 June launch was pulled back.

71 days
as pick
Pick 5 Feb 2026 – 1 Jul 2026Claude Opus 4.6

Took the top spot back from Gemini 3 Pro by leading Humanity's Last Exam and fixing context rot — and stayed Anthropic's arena leader eve…

146 days
as pick
Pick 18 Nov 2025 – 5 Feb 2026Gemini 3 Pro

Launched claiming the LMArena top spot outright at 1501 Elo — the first model past 1500 — alongside 91.9% GPQA Diamond.

79 days
as pick
Pick 7 Aug 2025 – 18 Nov 2025GPT-5

The unified reasoning-plus-router release retook the arena from Gemini 2.5 Pro and set state of the art across maths, coding and multimod…

103 days
as pick
Pick 25 Mar 2025 – 7 Aug 2025Gemini 2.5 Pro

Debuted directly at #1 on LMArena and turned the experimental streak into a stable, generally available product with a 1M-token context a…

135 days
as pick
Pick 6 Dec 2024 – 25 Mar 2025Gemini-Exp-1206

Google's experimental checkpoint line took the top spot off GPT-4o and never handed it back through Q1 2025, despite brief Grok 3 and GPT…

109 days
as pick
Pick 13 May 2024 – 6 Dec 2024GPT-4o

Reclaimed the crown for OpenAI at launch — after its anonymous "gpt2-chatbot" arena run broke records pre-announcement — and made native …

207 days
as pick
Pick 26 Mar 2024 – 13 May 2024Claude 3 Opus

The first non-OpenAI model ever to take #1 on Chatbot Arena, breaking a year of GPT-4 dominance on stronger reasoning and genuine long-fo…

48 days
as pick
Pick 1 Aug 2023 – 26 Mar 2024GPT-4 238 days
as pick